Twilight Soundtrack
Click here to visit the lds Church website
Take This Quiz!!!
Edward and Bella
Edward and Bella Poster
Twilight Siblings
Twilight Cast
Edward and Bella
Edward Cullen and James
Rosalie Hale
Jasper Hale
Carlisle Cullen
Emmett Cullen
Edward Cullen
Esme Cullen
Alice Cullen
Carlisle and Esme
6 comments:
How can it have been selfish? I know he had been thinking for who knows how long about being lonely, but I don't think the thought of changing Edward even crossed his mind until Edward's dying mother PUT the thought there, you know? I think it was better to give a dying man with no choice a choice rather than a perfectly healthy man who had different options no choice at all.
I am glad Carlisle changed him. He needed someone, and who better than someone he respected son. Ya know? Edwards mom KNEW Carlisle could do something- I think she could feel it- I am so glad he saved him!!! I think edward wishes he could have stayed human, for the human luxuries, Like LOVE but then he meets Bella and everything ends good! :)
Don't change folks into vampires...generally a bad practice, and I'm sure I read something about it in "For the Strength of Youth."
I think there were some selfish reasons, but for the most part was fulfilling his mother's wish to help Edward. In a way I think Edward has some resentment since he is trying to keep Bella from turning into a Vampire, but all in all is very grateful to Carlisle.
I agree with all the comments (though I'm not sure if it mentions vampire changing EXACTLY in FTSOY). Everybody needs somebody, and Carlisle didn't do it maliciously, and I don't think that Edward ever blamed who he was on Carlisle. I think Edward's battle against vampirism (if that's a word) was always internal.
Kristine~i see what you mean..i don't know how it could have been selfish, i think its completely unselfish to save somebodys life.
Ashley! totally see what ya mean!
Thrasher~NO comment
Patrick, Kendel and Emma~ i think so to, and think of how it would have been without carlisle..
Natalie~ yea i don't think there is anything about vampires in the FTSOF book either,the bishops just going crazy! i agree with you though!
Post a Comment